Avion Reserva 44

94 SCORE

“light citrus, peppery, good summer sipper! very light and yet subtle complex flavors!”

El Tesoro de Don Felipe Paradiso

91 SCORE

“smooth, peppery, caramel. Subtle sweetness (not too much). agreed I'm a cognac barrel - gives a very complex flavor. Generally excellent, but has a little edge that competes with the flavors.”

Don Abraham Extra Anejo

91 SCORE

“surprisingly smooth. great vanilla and caramel with just enough pepper. A thicker consistency, but still not too sweet. I think it's with for the shelf! Tierra Noble extra Anejo is a tad sweeter, less pepper, but a little smoother. both are on the same level for me ”

Chamucos Añejo

89 SCORE

“all good even flavors: pepper, cinnamon, a little vanilla, a little caramel. The more I drink, the more tired the alcohol flavor comes through. it needs other flavors to come through instead. El Agave said this is good, but the extra Anejo is even more popular. It might have more caramel flavor, which I think this needs. I need to try that!”

Cazcanes No. 7 Añejo

87 SCORE

“all good flavors, but the alcohol comes through a little strong. I should try the extra anejo ”

Tierra Noble Exquisito Extra Añejo

91 SCORE

“even better than they Anejo. not as sweet (surprisingly), more oak flavors: pepper, caramel, some vanilla. similar to 4 Copas Anejo, but more caramel and vanilla and a little sweeter. made in French oak & stainless steel. I think I might prefer the French oak vs American oak.”

123 Organic Tequila Reposado

86 SCORE

“maybe the lightest summer tequila I've had. not strong in any one flavor, but peppery, vanilla, & cinnamon. the anejo has even more vanilla flavor, but might be getting to sweet.”

El Tequileño "Sassenach Select" Reposado

90 SCORE

“light, pepper, multiple flavors, vanilla, cinnamon. very enjoyable”

4 Copas Reposado

90 SCORE

“extremely light repo. vanilla, peppery. a little sweet but not too much. basically a light version of the Anejo. however, it got sweeter as I sipped more. It's not as sweet as Tierra Noble Anejo though.”

Arette Gran Clase Extra Añejo

89 SCORE

“extremely smooth, amazing aroma, good flavors, some buron flavor (good), but too strong on the alcohol. still is enjoyable though. very light tasting for an extra Anejo.”

La Gritona Reposado

80 SCORE

“Recommended by Javier at El Agave on 3-18-23. Good flavors and finish, but not quite as smooth as I like. Drinkable & mostly enjoyable, but I would not consistently reach for it in the cabinet.”

El Tequileño Reposado Rare

90 SCORE

“Similar to Don Pilar extra anejo, but more peppery and not quite as smooth. complex with vanilla and oak. Amazing for what I'm told is a reposado. Aged 6 years! I'd still put it in the class of top favorites. $180 at Old Town 10'23. a little sweet though, so I don't reach for it as much as others”

El Tequileño Añejo Gran Reserva

83 SCORE

“smooth and peppery, but too sweet for me. has a tiny hint of burbon. Consider trying the repo. ”

Ocho Tequila Reposado

80 SCORE

“extremely smooth for a repo, but a little too sweet & too much agave flavor for me. ”

Casa Dragones Barrel Blend Añejo

83 SCORE

“very light, but noticable burbon barrel flavor. extremely smooth. I like it and would drink it again, but others are more favorite. $99/bottle”

Patrón El Alto Reposado Tequila

90 SCORE

“great flavors, but a little rough and subtle for the cost”

Don Pilar Extra Añejo

93 SCORE

“had with Michael & Madga, SKWS @ Javier's. smooth, bourbon barrel flavor, light pepper, not too sweet”

Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo

88 SCORE

“Very smooth with similar profile to Don Pilar, but not quite as good. has a stronger alcohol after taste. Mayte at El Agave said it's very sweet”