YourTequilaGuy rated 12h ago

Dos Primos Tequila Blanco

74 SCORE

“flavor is pleasant but kinda chaotic. way better than I thought it was going to be but not amazing. on the nose: raw agave, some cooked agave, grass, and citrus, mostly orange. on the palate: agave, black pepper out in front. bit of bitterness and ethanol but not unpleasant. long finish with heat but clean for the most part.”

Jared Rudolph rated 13h ago

Lost Lore Westbound Reposado

92 SCORE

“Much heavier than the other beer barrel expressions Lost Lore has put out. The stout influence is strong in the best possible way with a finish that lasts foreeeeever. Kudos for doing something very different.”

Bill Durnbaugh (Fuerte Fanatics / Agave Swappers / & DMV Tequila Club) rated 15h ago

Manuscrito Tequila Reposado - Chapter Three

87 SCORE

“Aroma: Earthy Cooked Agave and Cinnamon meet you immediately. Vanilla and Caramel are more forward than Oak, but all are present. Being familiar with Tobacco barns, there is a distinctive Tobacco and Musty quality that I just love! A touch of Herbalness reaches out as well. As this opens up over time, the Barrel influences become apparent with nice Baking Spices and an accompaniment of Cocoa Nibs. And a touch of Dried Fruit reaches out. Taste: Sweet Agave meets Vanilla and Caramel at the door! The Oak influence from being in the Barrel brings a nice Spice of Cinnamon, Nutmeg, and other Baking Spices. An abundance of Citrus is also available. The Herbalness from the nose carries over to the taste, along with the Dried Fruits of Apricot, Fig, And Plum. Finish: A very nice Medium length run of Sweet Agave runs with a Lingering Spice of Cinnamon and Baking Spices. ”

Eric Roeder rated 15h ago

Cascahuín Tahona Blanco

93 SCORE

“Just a great all-around tequila. Nice legs, good mouth feel. I get floral on the nose. citrus zest on the palate and some stone on the finish. Agave is prominent throughout. ”

Ben Rosenblatt rated 17h ago

Cazcanes No. 10 Still Strength Blanco

88 SCORE

“the #9 is good. the #10 is better. thicker, more luxurious mouthfeel and more highly concentrated agave flavor. also notes of pepper, citrus, earth, minerals, some salinity. I like this a lot. price drags the score down a hair”

Bryce Taylor rated 17h ago

El Ateo Antimateria Extra Añejo

86 SCORE

“You should know by now that El Ateo is making quality small batch tequila. I know it’s small batch because I’ve visited the distillery. This XA has aged for 3 years in American Oak barrels and it’s 40% ABV - 80 proof. On the nose it’s sweet cooked agave, barrels spice, caramel and heavy char Crème brûlée. The aromas are sweet and spicy. The flavors are similar to the nose but the palate / mouthfeel is thin. The flavors are pleasant and as full of flavor as a 40% ABV will allow. This is a full flavor sipper but I imagine that a higher proof version would be more interesting. ”

Ben Rosenblatt rated 18h ago

Cazcanes No. 9 Blanco

87 SCORE

“this is very good loses points on value. agave, vegetal, citrus, metallic, minerals. nice heat. good long finish. ”

Juan Chiu rated 19h ago

Tequila Xoloitzcuintle Reposado

87 SCORE

“Nose: Cooked agave, oak, spices, citrus, oranges Flavor: Cooked agave, oak, oranges, citrus, alcohol, spices, cinnamon, honey. Finish: medium finish with a little heat from the higher proof but still a delicious Reposado. Very little on the color but more sweetness from the barrel influence than I prefer. Still solid. ”

Shaun Mooney rated 20h ago

El Tesoro Tequila Reposado

91 SCORE

“El Tesoro Reposado Nose The nose opens with a balanced combination of light oak and wet minerality, supported by natural cooked agave sweetness. The barrel influence is present without dominating, allowing the agave to remain the focal point while adding warmth and depth. Taste (TNT) A rich, oily mouthfeel immediately coats the palate, leaving pronounced legs that cling beautifully to the glass. Sweet cooked agave is complemented by gentle tannins, black pepper, and warming cinnamon. The oak is well integrated, providing structure rather than overwhelming the tequila’s natural character. Finish The finish is long, warm, and spice-driven. Lingering oak and cinnamon are joined by a pleasant dryness from the tannins, while subtle vegetal fermentation emerges toward the end, adding complexity and keeping the finish unmistakably agave-forward. Overall El Tesoro Reposado is a textbook example of traditional reposado craftsmanship. The barrel enhances rather than masks the agave, creating a profile built on balance instead of excess. Rich texture, integrated oak, warming spice, and a touch of fermentation combine to produce a refined and highly drinkable tequila.”

Shaun Mooney rated 22h ago

Mijenta Cristalino Tequila Reposado

90 SCORE

“Mijenta Cristalino Nose Sweet cooked agave leads the aroma, complemented by tropical coconut notes that add brightness without becoming artificial. The nose is inviting and approachable, with the sweetness remaining balanced and integrated. Taste (TNT) A rich, viscous mouthfeel immediately coats the palate, leaving excellent legs in the glass. Natural agave sweetness is supported by warming cinnamon and black pepper, while subtle tropical coconut notes add another layer of complexity. Despite the sweeter profile, the tequila retains enough spice and texture to stay engaging. Finish The finish is warm and gently sweet, carrying lingering tropical nuances alongside black pepper, cinnamon, and vegetal fermentation. The combination creates a finish that is balanced and expressive, allowing the sweeter elements to coexist with the tequila’s agave-forward character. Overall Mijenta Cristalino offers a thoughtful interpretation of the category by maintaining the distillery’s agave identity while introducing tropical sweetness and refined barrel influence. The rich texture, balanced spice, and lingering fermentation prevent it from becoming overly dessert-like, resulting in a Cristalino that remains both approachable and complex.”

Shaun Mooney rated 22h ago

Mijenta Reposado Symphony Series No. 2

92 SCORE

“Mijenta Symphony Series No. 2 Nose The nose immediately showcases elegant oak influence with inviting notes of caramel and butterscotch layered over natural cooked agave sweetness. The barrel complements rather than dominates, creating a warm, expressive aroma that remains balanced and approachable. Taste (TNT) Cooked agave sweetness leads the palate before giving way to warming cinnamon and black pepper. The mouthfeel is rich, thick, and silky, coating the tongue and leaving pronounced legs in the glass. The flavors are well integrated, allowing the sweetness, spice, and texture to work together without one overpowering the others. Finish The finish is long and warming, yet surprisingly cooling on the exhale. Lingering vegetal notes, natural fermentation, and a subtle black licorice character add depth and complexity while maintaining balance. The finish evolves gracefully, inviting another sip. Overall Symphony Series No. 2 is a beautifully composed expression that layers barrel character over Mijenta’s agave-forward foundation without losing its identity. The interplay of caramel, butterscotch, cooked agave, pepper, and fermentation creates a profile that feels both luxurious and balanced. Its rich texture and evolving finish make it a standout in the lineup.”

Shaun Mooney rated 22h ago

Mijenta Blanco Maestra Selection No. 2

90 SCORE

“Mijenta Maestra Selection No. 2 Nose The nose opens with pronounced minerality supported by delicate floral aromas. A subtle nutty character adds warmth and depth, while black pepper provides a gentle lift. The aromas are more focused and cohesive, creating a clean, inviting profile. Taste (TNT) A rich, warming palate immediately showcases the tequila’s higher proof without overwhelming the agave. Black pepper leads the flavor profile, balanced by a silky, full-bodied mouthfeel. The texture is thick and oily, clinging beautifully to the glass and coating the palate with each sip. The profile feels clean, integrated, and confident. Finish The finish is warm, long, and satisfying. Natural fermentation lingers well after the sip, adding complexity while allowing the pepper and cooked agave to remain at center stage. The finish leaves a lasting impression without introducing distracting or competing notes. Overall Mijenta Maestra Selection No. 2 delivers a richer and more cohesive experience than expected. The combination of minerality, floral aromas, pepper, and a luxurious mouthfeel creates an elegant, well-balanced tequila that remains true to its agave-forward character. The lingering fermentation on the finish adds depth without overpowering the profile, making this a memorable and enjoyable pour.”

Shaun Mooney rated 23h ago

Mijenta Blanco Maestra Selection No. 1

88 SCORE

“Mijenta Maestra Selection No. 1 Nose Freshly opened, the initial pour presents a noticeable alcohol presence that masks some of the underlying aromas. With time in the glass, cooked agave begins to emerge alongside vegetal notes, bright citrus, wet minerality, and a subtle briny character reminiscent of sea air. The aromas are intriguing, but they remain somewhat reserved and require effort to fully uncover. Taste (TNT) The palate opens with black pepper and warming cinnamon, immediately showcasing the tequila’s higher proof. Cooked agave provides a touch of natural sweetness that balances the spice, while fermented notes and a subtle black licorice character add depth. The mouthfeel is rich, thick, and oily, coating the palate and leaving pronounced legs in the glass. Despite the quality of the individual components, the overall profile never quite comes together into a seamless whole. Finish The finish is long and warming with lingering pepper and cooked agave. A noticeable tannic quality develops late, creating the impression of light barrel influence despite this being a blanco. Whether that character comes from fermentation or production techniques rather than oak, it introduces an unexpected twist that leaves the finish feeling more puzzling than satisfying. Overall Mijenta Maestra Selection No. 1 is clearly a thoughtfully crafted, high-quality tequila with excellent texture and plenty of complexity. The minerality, fermentation, and oily mouthfeel all point to careful production. However, on this first pour, the nose feels muted, the palate lacks complete harmony, and the finish introduces notes that don’t fully resonate with my palate. This is a bottle I’ll revisit after it has had time to open up, as I suspect additional air may help reveal its full character.”

Carl Evans rated 1d ago

Manuscrito Cuento Corto: Special Blend Rested Blanco

90 SCORE

“Great oily mouth feel with good agave flavor and sweet cinnamon. Very enjoyable.”

Jared Rudolph rated 1d ago

Cierto Tequila Private Collection Extra Añejo

83 SCORE

“Good, but feels a bit muted compared to the other fantastic 1146 XAs. And that price, ooof.”

Jon Novak rated 1d ago

Corrido Blanco

86 SCORE

“Vegetal and pepper on the nose. Palate is fine. Nothing to rave about but a decent sipper ”